Search Now

Recommendations

Showing posts with label Shringar Cinemas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shringar Cinemas. Show all posts

Sunday, June 17, 2007

Shringar Cinemas: Buy


An investment can be considered in the stock of Shringar Cinemas, which runs the Fame chain of multiplexes. The stock is at a deep discount to its peers at about 18 times its financial year 07 per-share earnings; industry leader PVR Cinemas trades at 48 times financial year 07 earnings. Stocks of multiplex majors have been under pressure in recent months. The year, so far, has been a lacklustre one for Indian films, raising concerns about occupancy rates even as markets get overcrowded in some pockets. This, coupled with the growing power of distributors, who are demanding a higher share of ticket revenues, has resulted in a more subdued outlook for multiplexes.

In this backdrop, we tend to view a stock such as Shringar, with its more reasonable valuations, in a favourable light. Investors who wish to capitalise on the long-term potential arising from a growing preference for multiplexes could consider exposure to the stock. The company has about a 10 per cent market share of the multiplex industry (in terms of number of screens) as against that of PVR Cinemas at 20 per cent. About 23 screens are likely to come up in financial year 08 with the properties already handed over to the multiplex operator. With Shringar now firmly in the black, the fundamental picture is looking brighter. Strong revenue growth is likely to continue on the back of screen additions, as new multiplexes tend to draw footfalls. If the second half turns out to be a better period for tinsel town, occupancy rates for Shringar could be much stronger than the current 30 per cent levels. This, in turn, could lead to a strong uptick in earnings. We believe that Shringar's own presence in distribution, which accounts for about 30 per cent of its consolidated revenues, will make it better placed than operators of comparable size in securing good content at reasonable prices.

The stock however is suitable only for those with an appetite for higher risk. The dependence on good content aside, issues such as high rentals (as it continues its expansion in cities such as Mumbai and Bangalore), the need to constantly refurbish theatres to ward off competition and overcrowding in some locations are risks to our recommendation.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Religare - PNB, Shringar Cinema, Tulip IT,


Religare on PNB

We are positive on PNB considering that core operational performance remains
robust and the lower-than-expected profitability in FY07 was largely on account of
one-off items. Further, PNB’s initiative to create provisions towards AS-15 guidelines
ahead of their implementation would safeguard future profitability, while the BPLR
hike in April would protect margins. The robust growth in fee income is also a positive
sign. While the continuous increase in NPAs and the unexpected announcement of an
equity offering are concerns, we expect the bank to maintain its steady growth
trajectory in the coming year.

Recommend Buy with target of Rs 610

The stock currently trades at 1.3x on FY09E ABV. We recommend Buy on the stock

Religare on Shringar Cinemas

At the current level the stock is quoting at 15.9x and 10.1x its FY08 and FY09
expected earnings respectively. The following table depicts the comparative analysis
of various multiplex players.

DCF valuation yields fair value of Rs 75; HoldWe have undertaken a DCF valuation in order to capture the growth momentum of the company.
Our DCF model estimates a fair value of Rs 75/share for Shringar, based
initiated coverage; Hold on a terminal growth rate of 4%, beta of 1.01 and a weighted average cost of capital (WACC) of 15.1%. The stock has appreciated 17% since we initiated coverage on 22 May 2007. We now recommend a Hold with a target price of Rs 75.


Religare on Tulip IT


We have valued the company using a sum-of-the-parts (SOTP) valuation model that
An attractive long-term employs the two-stage discounted cash flow (DCF) and EV/EBIT multiple valuation investment; Buy methods. Taking the average of target prices arrived at using the two methods, we have a March 2008 target of Rs 932 for the stock. At the CMP of Rs 875, the upside is limited to 6%, but we believe the company offers a good opportunity for long-term investment. We recommend a Buy on the stock.

Sunday, April 15, 2007

Multi flex


Aggressive expansion into non-metro markets will turn the wheels of fortune for the multiplex industry.
Five years back, it would have been a job of a visionary to imagine large format retail malls, hypermarkets and multi-screen film exhibition theatres or multiplexes all at one place, in all the prime locations of every city. Today with most prime locations in the metros boasting of multiplexes, the spotlight is on the film exhibition industry.
The cinema exhibition segment has traditionally been the dominant contributor to the rising prosperity of Indian film entertainment industry, the size of which is estimated to be about Rs 8,400 crore currently.
According to a recent FICCI-Pricewaterhouse Coopers report titled Frames 2007, this industry is expected to grow at a compounded annual rate of 16 per cent over the next five years, roughly doubling to Rs 17,500 crore by the year 2011. Exhibition of films contributes over 85 per cent to this kitty, with the domestic box office revenues bringing in about 75 per cent plus, traditionally.
Macro optimism
In 2006, domestic box office revenues grew by about 21 per cent, as blockbusters like Dhoom 2, Lage Raho Munnabhai, Krrish, Fanaa and Rang De Basanti amassed over Rs 300 crore. At present, the domestic box office market is pegged at Rs 6,400 crore, and is expected to grow at a compounded rate of 13.5 per cent.
At this rate, the market would double in size to Rs 11,900 crore by 2011. With the multiplex boom, the average ticket prices (ATPs) on an all-India basis have grown from Rs 20 to Rs 35 per ticket, and close to Rs 100 per ticket in metro cities.
On the flipside, it is expected that the share of box office revenues will reduce in the overall entertainment business, considering the growth of home video and exhibition of films over broadcast networks.
However, the segment will remain strong, contributing nearly 70 per cent, due to increasing demand in Tier II and Tier III cities where multiplexes are just being rolled-out.
“Tier II and Tier III cities would now be the new playground to compete on, for almost all the multiplex companies,” claims Sanjeev Hota of Emkay Shares and Stockbrokers. “Over 65 per cent of the total box office collections in the country come from non-metros,” he adds.
The boom in the sector will not just ride on high demand. The advent of digitisation of cinema exhibition too, will help a great deal. More and more producers and distributors are emphasising on digitisation to combat piracy.
Digital prints are less prone to illegal duplication as well as cheaper compared to their analogue counterparts. In addition to this, satellite delivery of prints too, will help curb piracy, thus attracting higher footfalls in theatres.
Reaching out
In order to reach out to a wider geography all the players are aggressively expanding into new locations. Adlabs, the largest player by market capitalisation and revenues, currently operates 13 multiplexes in eight cities with 50 screens and over 16,000 seats.
It plans to set up another 200-plus screens by 2010. PVR Cinemas too, is looking at adding about 50-60 screens in 8 locations in east India within the next five years.
“We expect to exceed our projections and launch about 100 screens at 32 locations, taking the count of seats to around 25,000 by the end of FY08,” says Rasesh Kanakia, chairman, Cinemax India.
Inox too, plans to launch about 10-12 new multiplexes in tier II cities such as Lucknow, Raipur and Faridabad in FY08. Pyramid Saimira, a dominant player in south India, is planning to set up around 300 mall-cum-multiplex projects over the coming few years.
Among the unlisted players, Apollo Group’s United Film Organisers (UFO) has about 585 digital cinemas, which it plans to increase to 2000, at an investment of Rs 300 crore. Essel Group’s E-city Ventures which operates Fun Cinemas and Fun Republic projects to increase its current count of 125 screens to 150 by December 2008, thus boasting of over 35 multiplexes across the country.
Micro pessimism
Indeed, for multiplex companies to flourish, it is necessary that they roll-out new multiplexes on a continual basis. Rising interest rates and sky-high real estate prices pose a roadblock to expansion.
“Since the existing multiplex companies have by and large tapped the equity markets, they now need to procure debt in order to make capital expenditure. This would raise the cost of their projects due to high interest rates,” says Gaurav Chugh, analyst, IL&FS Investsmart.
A delay in execution too, could postpone the launches of new multiplexes. “Inability to execute projects in time would further delay the break even of projects, and thus hold back the company’s future earnings,” says Chugh. Here, companies with experience in developing their own properties will have an edge over the rest.
“Therefore, players like Cinemax, Inox and PVR will manage to ride the tide of high real estate prices and delays in execution,” points out an analyst. On the other hand, players like Shringar Cinema, which have less experience in real estate as compared to peers, may take a hit.
“We have already tied up all the properties required for our expansion until the year 2009, and hence are almost immune to high real estate prices currently,” claims a confident Rasesh Kanakia, Cinemax.
Alok Tandon, chief operating officer, Inox Leisure says: “Most of our properties are on a long lease of around 20-24 years. Four out of 14 of our properties are owned. In addition, in the new properties that we sign, we get considerably lower rentals as compared to other occupants of a mall or a property being the anchor tenant.” An anchor tenant is the main tenant in a shopping centre.
Besides, there are certain state governments, which pose regulatory restrictions in terms of capping of ticket prices for multiplexes. “At present, Rajasthan does not allow multiplexes to increase ticket prices for more than once a year, and not more than 15 per cent, while Tamil Nadu has capped the price to Rs 120 per ticket,” says Tandon of Inox.
However, considering the increasing contribution of food and beverage sales and other revenue streams such as gaming which provide higher margins, lower ticket prices would be compensated. Usually, food and beverages contribute around 30 per cent of the total revenues of a multiplex player.
Some players are going a step further to augment revenues and margins. For instance, Cinemax launched Red Lounge in Mumbai, a premium multiplex in an exclusive lounge format with reclining seats, massage chairs and karaoke facilities which commands an ATP of around Rs 350 and above, along with launching Giggles Gaming Zones at all its multiplexes to augment footfalls.

SHOW ME THE MONEY

Rs crore

Revenue Net Profit EPS (Rs) PE(x)
FY08E FY09E FY08E FY09E FY08E FY09E FY08E FY09E
Adlabs Films 365.30 413.00 73.10 82.60 18.40 20.80 23.50 20.70
Cinemax 182.00 206.00 32.60 37.10 11.60 13.20 11.00 9.70
Inox Leisure 185.80 209.90 30.30 34.20 5.10 5.70 23.00 20.60
PVR 195.00 220.40 13.70 15.40 5.40 6.00 32.50 29.30
Pyramid Saimira 131.10 157.30 12.50 15.30 4.40 5.40 68.80 56.00
Shringar Cinema 69.30 78.30 11.40 12.90 3.60 4.00 14.80 13.30
Adlabs is making a foray in the content production business, by picking up stakes in companies like Synergy Communications (and plans to pick up a stake in Miditech), which have a proven track record. Players like Shringar and Inox have forayed into film production and distribution.
Inox is also setting up low-cost multiplexes, in order to tap growth in smaller towns. Pyramid Saimira has plans to set up retail malls and budget hotels along with multiplexes in partnership with Baderwals Infraprojects and Shriram Malls.
Compete more
Even as there seems to be huge demand for multiplexes, increasing competition is a concern. In order to woo higher footfalls and augment occupancy levels some multiplexes are offering discounts on ticket prices, which may hold back a rise in ATPs and margins, in turn.
“The differences in ticket prices are too specific to various locations. Similar is the case for our costs,” says Alok Tandon, Inox, adding that it is not a serious threat.
“ATPs are rising steadily in metros. In non-metros, although ATPs are low, they are compensated by high incremental demand,” says Hota of Emkay. IL&FS’ Chugh is optimistic suggesting that, “newer players entering the business confirms the healthy state of the sector for the coming years.”
Valuations
Over the past year, all the players in the segment have taken a beating. The valuations of Inox and PVR, for instance, eroded more than 40 per cent over the year. Adlabs however has managed to stay afloat riding on a fairly diverse composition of business, with forays in film production, distribution and FM radio.

FRESH BLITZ
Multiplexes Current
Screens
Seats Projected in
next 5 years
PVR 17 67 16,578 208
Inox Leisure 11 41 12,299 165
Cinemax 9 29 8,260 141
Shringar 7 30 9,051 168
Adlabs 7 26 9,146 225
Source: FICCI-PwC Report: Frames 2007
Due to varied composition of businesses, it is difficult to compare these companies going solely by price-earnings multiple. In spite of this, Adlabs and Inox at about 23 and 20 times their expected FY08 and FY09 earnings, respectively, appear to be reasonably valued considering their expansion plans and their proven ability to execute their plans. Adlabs however has a significant upside potential, in case it hives-off its radio business into a separate unit, thus unlocking value.
In comparison, Cinemax appears cheap, but it has to improve its operating margins from around 14 per cent currently to about 18 per cent, which is normal across the industry. The upside from Pyramid Saimira’s aggressive expansion and diversification plans appears to be already factored in its valuation.
On the other hand, even though Shringar Cinema appears fairly valued, concerns loom large over its turnaround efforts as well as its ability to execute its expansion plan. With continuing uncertainty prevailing across the board in broader markets, investors may want to bet on this sector as it offers enough variety to suit different tastes.

Saturday, February 03, 2007

Sunday, December 24, 2006

The on-screen multiplier effect


Three leading multiplex operators — Shringar Cinemas, PVR and Inox Leisure — have entered the listed space over the past two years. The promise of a superior experience relative to other entertainment options; the ability to charge higher admission rates than single-screen theatres; rapid expansion plans; and the onset of a "new and improved" Indian film industry that focuses on content, were factors that helped these companies trade at a premium valuation, post-listing, along the lines of retailing majors.

Post the correction in mid-caps, the stocks of Shringar Cinemas and PVR are now trading at levels closer to their offer price, even as Inox Leisure has fallen significantly from its earlier high.

While valuations have corrected, they remain on the high side. Although the demand for multiplexes from the cinema-going public shows no signs of weakening, problems in execution of expansion plans, coupled with the high risks associated with the business, could temper valuations. We analyse the performance of multiplexes in the post-offer period and provide an outlook for the stocks in the sector.

Robust revenue growth

Multiplex operators have recorded strong growth in revenues in the range of 40-60 per cent in the first half of FY-07, on the back of new multiplex additions. It has also been an exceptionally good year for the Indian film industry, which saw the release of a slew of successful films. High occupancy rates have persisted, allowing theatres to hike rates in the first few weeks of a film's release. Profit growth has outpaced sales growth, as overheads such as personnel and maintenance costs have been spread over a larger base.

The robust performance cannot eclipse the risk of sudden knocks in performance if the content suffers. Strong inflows from box office collections have, however, so far reduced the impact of a slower-than-expected rollout of theatre chains.

Problems in execution

The market has been factoring in a multi-fold expansion in properties across theatre chains. However, delays in receiving Government approvals and handover of properties from developers have slowed down the roll-out of theatres. A large portion of offer proceeds remain unutilised for most players, although this has not stopped Shringar Cinemas from raising foreign convertible debt of about Rs 90 crore to fund its expansion plans.

The stated expansion plans across the three contenders continue to be ambitious; companies expect to double and triple the number of screens they operate over the next two to three years. Screen additions are likely to bunch up in some quarters, which could skew the quarterly performance picture in a manner similar to what is being witnessed in the retail industry.

PVR appears to have managed a faster rollout than its peers and now appears to be fairly ahead of Inox Leisure when it comes to screen presence. This could be why it continues to trade at a premium to the other players.

Tussle with distributors

Scale is becoming increasingly important for multiplex operators. While a good box-office year has had cash registers ringing, distributors are not too happy with exhibitors walking away with a greater share of the profits. Multiplexes account for barely 5 per cent of the total screens in India but are estimated to rake in 30-40 per cent of box-office revenues every year, thanks to their ability to charge higher ticket rates.

Big banner productions such as Fanaa, Dhoom-2 and Baabul have had distributors demanding more favourable terms in the revenue-sharing agreements. Those who have succumbed to their pressure have seen pressure on margins. The distributor's share is one of the more significant expenses borne by operators, accounting for more than 20 per cent of revenues. Inox Leisure, for instance, has seen a rise of 700 basis points in distributor's share in the first half of FY-07.

Such instances are likely to crop up till multiplexes gain scale; operators now see merit in consolidating their presence in certain distributor territories to improve their bargaining power with distributors. They are also getting into distribution themselves to ensure supply of content for their exhibition business.

Stock view

Given that expansion plans were at an early stage, we had maintained that it would be difficult to pick one of the three as a superior exposure and had earlier recommended holding at least two of the three stocks. We remain positive on the sector and maintain our stance. Despite execution problems, we believe that the ramp up in revenues and earnings would be significant.

Among the three players, PVR is more expensively valued. Its larger scale and better execution capabilities appears to drive its premium valuation. Its foray into co-production for two films with Aamir Khan Productions, due for release in 2007, also appears promising. Higher share of theatres that carry tax benefits could also help scale up margins. However, given the stiff valuation, tolerance to poor quarterly performance would be low. Shareholders can hold the stock and investors can consider accumulation on declines.

While Inox Leisure is relatively more attractive, concerns stem from the steep decline in margins it has witnessed recently, on account of rising payout of entertainment tax and distributors' share. Inox has enjoyed higher-than-average operating margins thanks to its operating from locations that are exempt from tax. Sustaining this advantage might prove difficult. Retain holdings of the stock.

Shringar Cinemas' performance appears to be turning the corner, reversing losses in the first two quarters. Additional screens could result in a substantial improvement in revenues and earnings. Shringar's long experience in the distribution business will also be to its advantage once it gains scale. Execution, however, continues to be an issue as the company has been slow to roll out properties. Investors with an appetite for risk can consider exposure in the stock.