In a candid interview with CNBC-TV18’s
“If the Nifty breaks 4650 decisively and holds for a week or so, it could hit 5900-6000,” Jhunjhunwala said. The markets would consolidate between 4,000-5,000 for three-four years, he added.
The correction seen in the latter part of 2008, he said, was a part of a major bull run that continues and which started in September 2001. “The bull market started in September 2001. We had the first leg up to September 2002 after which there was a correction. Then it started from April 2003, that leg lasted till 21,000,” the ace investor said. “That gets corrected back now to 7,500-8,000 and now we have resumed that bull market. So we can go to 20,000 and again come back to 16,000-15,000, make a range and then make a move which goes above 21,000.”
Q: We spoke on the day after the election results. I do not think even we imagined the market would be here. What is the screen telling you now?
A: The screen is telling me that the bear correction of the larger bull market in
Despite people’s apprehension and doubts about the economic scenario worldwide, it could be that the fall [in 2008] was just a correction. I also feel so because of the way the [subsequent] rise took place with its tremendous breadth, tremendous pace with good volumes — but with a lot of cynicism and lack of participation among the larger people.
Q: You do not agree with the consensus feeling right now that we should be scared by the pace of the rise. That we are now approaching a mini bubble kind of a situation?
A: You first asked what the screen was saying, you never asked me what my opinion was.
Just like others, there is a fair amount of doubt in my mind too. Internationally, things are not clear at all and I do not think that the downturn in the western economies — even if there is some kind of an improvement in the next 12-24 months — has really peaked. So with that knowledge about the world economy, it clouds the judgement of what can happen in
However, If you look at the other side of the story, I see no reason why — if Indian software exports grow by 10-15%, commodity prices hold at reasonable levels and we have good government policies —
The fact is that market is just going up in an unexpected pace and everybody is worrying. Surely I am also apprehensive about the valuation and the pace but markets are markets.
Q: When you look at the screen, what worries you? Does it worry you that valuations are far ahead of fundamentals or do you see the kind of participation or mania that you saw in 2007 or that is not visible just yet?
A: Not at all, not even 5%. I don’t go to any cocktail party where stock markets are even talked because everybody is totally left out. And the futures positions are indicative, the number of calls you get, the apprehension that people have in the buy stocks — I don’t know where the buyers are coming from but I don’t think there is even 20% of the participation of that what was in 2007.
Q: Will they all get sucked in you think before this rally tops out, people who have been sitting out?
A: It is very difficult to leave a burning cigarette in a rising market. Everybody will ultimately join. I don’t know how many calls I got when we made a 52-week high. Normally, a lot of channels call me, no channel called me to get an opinion when the market was at a 52-week high. I don’t even know how many people know we were at a 52-week high.
So I think crowd psychology-wise or sentiment-wise, I don’t think at all we are anywhere near any kind of a top.
Q: Are you trading yourself with a bit more caution because you were saying you are also in two minds right now or are you trading the kind of volumes you were trading in the big momentum of 2007?
A: I don’t think I am trading the way II was in 2007. After all, I am a human too and I am also affected by what my thoughts are. However, I am far surer about the [country’s] longer-term growth prospects and the strength than most people.
Q: Why did you pick out the level 4,000? Any significance or do you think below that…
A: Instead of 4,000, I would say 3,800 or maybe even 3,600 — no level is sacrosanct — but I would say the level where this market made a gap, that should not be violated on the downside. If it breaks 4,650 decisively, that’s what my technical analyst tells me, that market will make or at least challenge the previous high of 6,100.
Q: Do you think 6,100 is possible in 2009?
A: Did you think 4,500 was possible?
Q: I am asking you.
A: Ok. What the technical analyst says — and I also think — if it breaks 4,650 decisively on a weekly basis and holds it for a week or two, then surely we can go to 5,800-5,900-6,000 levels. We could go there, then come back to 5,000-5,200 or maybe 4,800-4,500, make a range and consolidate for a year or so and then make a new high. Another scenario: we break 4,650, we are going to go to 5,850-5,900-6,000, come back to somewhere around 3,300-3,400 and maybe spend three-four years there.
Q: Do you think that’s also possible — that the market goes there, halves from there and then spends a big…
A: It happened in 1991. So at this moment, I won’t rule out any of the scenarios but I am more inclined towards the first that we will reach 5,800-5900-6000 and then we consolidate — maybe in the 4,500-5,000 or 4,600-5,200 or even 4,000-5,000 range for the next 12-18 months. Then we go into a new high — 6,100 — and go upwards or we go back to 3,000 to 4,000 where we spend two-three years to resume higher.
Q: What is your best guess for the rest of 2009? Do you think we will actually go to 5,800-5,900 in 2009?
A: I have put a lot of caveats there — that the index should cross 4,650 decisively on a weekly basis, hold for a week or two, then I think it should. I don’t know where and what range the markets go into, but they will go into a range, spend time and only then are we going to see a big move. We have already seen a big move, we don’t know whether this move will end at: 4,800, 5,800, 5,900, 6,000? I think it will surely end before 6,000.
I do not think the Sensex will cross 21,000 in a straight line. We have to correct and we have to make a range and only then we can have the next move.
Q: Range in terms of price or time?
A: Price.
Q: And that range according to you is?
A: Who knows where it will be.
Q: What is your best case?
A: I think it will be anywhere between 3,800 and 5,000.
Q: That big a range?
A: The range could be narrower but 3,800 would be the bottom and 5,000 would be the top in that range. The range could be 4,000 to 4,500, it could be 4,500 to 5,000.
Q: After that you think a bigger bull market will commence, which goes to a new high?
A: The bull market, which has started in September 2001. We had a bull market up to 2008, we had the first leg up to September 2002 after which there was a correction. Then it started from April 2003, that leg lasted till 21,000.
That gets corrected back now to 7,500-8,000 and now we have resumed that bull market. So we can go to 20,000 and again come back to 16,000-15,000, make a range and then make a move which goes above 21,000.
Q: Right now what sums up your state of mind: wildly optimistic, terribly and totally bullish or cautiously bullish?
A: All three.
Q: With an accent on what, the caution or the bullishness?
A: I am cautious.
Q: Why? You said yourself that nobody is participated; the gaon is not into stocks.
A: I am also part of the gaon.
Q: You are a sophisticated member of the gaon.
A: Even the sophisticated ones are caught.
Q: What is making you cautious? You said valuations are not crazy and who are we to say valuations are excessive? Is it global cues which you think may turn?
A: Yes, it is the sheer psychology of the fact that the global economy is in a terrible downturn. That is put into our brains.
Q: It is not the experience of the horrific 2008?
A: No, not all that. We have had more horrific experiences.
Q: Have you? 60% down in one year?
A: Yes, why not? ‘92, though I made a lot of money back then by shorting but we also 2000, which was the worst year when from 6,000, you came back to 2,900.
Q: So the fear is global, nothing else?
A: Yes, the fear is global.
via CNBC-TV18/Moneycontrol.com