In a great book, "The art of Contrary Thinking", the author, Humphrey B. Neil, recounts events where contrary thinking helped.
“I’m sometimes asked about unexpected (and unsuspected) events of the past, when contrary ruminating might have been useful in mental preparedness and when contrary planning might have saved losses to nations as well as to peoples. Here are a few; many more might be added.
1914 | Little general apprehension of war. Newspapers carried scarcely any mention of strained relations prior to mid-July, 1914. | Yet—black headlines soon appeared: Aug. 1— Aug. 2— Aug. 4— Aug. 5— |
A stunned world looked on believing | ||
1916 | Sensational rise in stocks of “war babies” and general stockmarket boom expected to continue. | Year-long bear market set in in November, 1916. By December, 1917, market average almost returned full cycle. |
1919 | Immediate postwar depression generally expected and predicted. | Inflation boom occurred, to be nicknamed the “silk shirt era.” |
1926 | Fears of another bear market and depression. | “New Era” commenced, with greatest market rise in history. |
1929 | Permanent plateau of prosperity. | New Era delusions shattered. |
1930’s | Economics: We reached the age of “maturity.” World Politics: Why worry about the little paperhanger and his Nazis? | Economic maturity laughable, but Hitler no laughing matter! War in 1939 expected but “it can’t last long.” Hitler “has no money and no powerful armies.” |
1940 | Hitler could never breach famed French Maginot line; | The “blitzkrieg” overran |
1945-1946 | Immediate postwar slump expected, with eight to twelve million to be unemployed. | As in1919, a postwar “replacement” boom made all predictions look silly. |
1949 | | September 18, pound devalued to $2.80; currencies of 29 other nations following suit—and as many more since. |
1947-1954 | Persistent predictions of a slump were common. | Booming conditions largely prevailed; there were only brief interruptions. |
1955-1957 | The years when fears of slumps vanished and the idea of perpetual prosperity became the fad. | Stock market collapsed in mid-’57 just when the future looked brightest. |
1961 | Mania for growth. Stocks fomented a great speculative era; hundreds of companies “went public”; and a greedy public grabbed for the shares at fast-rising prices. | As in manias of the past, the cruel awakening came in the summer of ’62, as stock prices plunged. Again, it paid to be contrary! |
And so we come to the end of our narratives and essays on THE ART OF CONTRARY THINKING.
The writer’s hope is that you, the reader, will follow through with persistent thinking on the Theory of Contrary Opinion to the end that it may develop into clearer thinking on the world’s intense and complex subjects.”